|
|

Plato and the lunar Alps |
What the Moon actually is has interested people for millennia, at least. In pre-Christian times the celestial bodies were not just divine, but in some views the divinities themselves. The Moon, being close, bright and highly regular in its phases and position, was thought to influence the Earth in many ways, and so was thought to be a cosmic power with an identity and being, in different aspects, of its own. The ancient Greeks were interested in what the heavens were actually made of and how they were structured, and they propounded as many theories of the Moon as any other planet. Parmenides himself indicated our modern understanding of moonlight: nightshining round earth a wanderer with borrowed light Others thought the Moon was merely a stone. Some thought it was a stone whose pores leaked light from the heavenly world. Opinion differed on whether the Moon was flat or spherical. Aetius reported that the Pythagorean, Philolaos, had said the Moon was Earthlike and supported plants and animals fifteen times larger than terrestrial plants and animals. Others explained that, like all the objects in the sky, the Moon was made of the celestial fire, a pure, ethereal fire as opposed to the material fire found on Earth. This belief was held widely well into the Renaissance, and provides one of the main metaphors in Dante's celestial cosmology. On leaving Eden at the top of Mount Purgatory to embark for heaven, Dante and Beatrice pass through a final purifying wall of fire into the sphere of the Moon. In the fifteenth century, da Vinci thought the changes he detected in the Moon's surface appearance were caused by clouds rising from water. With inferences like this, modern, inductive, observational science begins. Galileo, looking through his telescope, changed the world's lunar theories for good. He thought the dark areas he saw were literally large bodies of water, and he called them "seas." In 1651 Giambattista Riccioli followed Galileo's lead when he mapped and named the dark areas as bodies of water, for example, Lacus Somniorum, the Lake of Dreams, and Mare Tranquillitatis, the Sea of Tranquillity |
(site of Apollo 11's landing). He named craters after philosophers and scientists, and his nomenclature became generally accepted. But he thought the names merely apt conventions. For religious reasons, he believed neither water nor inhabitants existed on the Moon. Riccioli's Christian conviction was a direct descendant, coming down through Aristotle, St. Augustine, Dante and other religious thinkers, of the sense that the stars and planets are made of a divine, immaterial substance. As the methods of objective science gained authority, the Moon's divinity dissolved. Reputable eighteenth century astronomers conjectured that the Moon was Earthlike and had an atmosphere and grew plants. An early nineteenth century German astronomer speculated that the rilles, long cracks in the Moon's surface, were roads, and announced at one point that he had discovered a lunar city. Soon afterward, the astronomers Beer and Madler explained the Moon's surface features in detailed geological terms, and the modern view of a dead, rocky Moon settled into place. To be sure, no one was unequivocally certain about the Moon's deadness. Peculiar changes of light, for example, that could not be objectively explained, continued to occur on the Moon. A reddish light glows in some craters from time to time, unpredictably. Astronomers call these glows "Lunar Transient Events," but have no idea what they are. They still occur, unexplained, today. Astronomy textbooks give the general feeling that the glows are illusions of some kind that are either minor physical peculiarities or more likely don't concern science at all. We do know, now, that the Moon is a lifeless ball of rock. Shortly before Apollo 11 landed on the Sea of Tranquillity in July 1969, most scientists were reasonably certain that the Moon was airless and waterless, rocky rather than icy. Apollo 8 had flown around it 10 times at Christmas of 1968 and said so. The astronauts described pretty much exactly what the scientists expected they would. Only the fine details were still uncertain. For example, there was concern that the Moon might be harboring alien microbes with the potential to cause mass infection on the Earth, so mission planners quarantined the astronauts after the first few Apollo landings. Some geologists were concerned that Moon rocks suddenly exposed to oxygen in the spacecraft might burst into flames. At least one reputable scientist was convinced that the Moon was covered with a very light powder, into which Neil Armstrong, Buzz Aldrin and the Eagle would disappear forever. But in general the most conventional theories were borne out. Eagle landed on firm soil. The astronauts found only rocks and dust. Gravity was low. Nothing moved that the astronauts did not kick up themselves. The Moon's mountains and plains looked different from any Earth landscape, but this too was generally predictable. Armstrong reported that the landscape appeared amazingly sharp and clear because of the lack of atmosphere, but he found it difficult to judge sizes and distances because there was nothing familiar for comparison. In brilliant sunlight the rolling land |
Magnificent Desolation |